Saturday, 6 May 2017

Doctor Who: Thin Ice - Poll Results

For the past week you've been voting in our rate the episode poll for Thin Ice. We've now closed the poll and you can view the results below:

After last week's lukewarm response, Thin Ice saw a tick up in positivity as a comfortable majority of fans opted to give the episode 4/5 or 5/5, with fewer negative votes to match, even if it fell short of the 'fan favourite' mark:
  • Amazing (5/5) - 32.88%
  • Very good (4/5) - 47.95%
  • OK (3/5) - 9.59%
  • Poor (2/5) - 6.85%
  • Awful (1/5) - 2.74%
The episode had an average score of 4.01/5, a very respectable result that sees a substantial rise from Smile, though it doesn't quite match up to the response that the premiere episode received. That slots it into the middle of our (slowly growing) Series 10 leaderboard:
  1. The Pilot - 4.15
  2. Thin Ice - 4.01
  3. Smile - 3.64
In the context of the whole Capaldi era, Thin Ice slots into the lower middle of the pack amongst Last Christmas and The Caretaker:

  1. Face the Raven - 4.57
  2. The Witch's Familiar - 4.55
  3. Listen - 4.54
  4. The Zygon Inversion - 4.53
  5. Flatline - 4.48
  6. Mummy on the Orient Express - 4.47
  7. The Magician's Apprentice - 4.454
  8. Heaven Sent 4.450
  9. Dark Water - 4.43
  10. Under the Lake - 4.37
  11. The Husbands of River Song - 4.23
  12. Deep Breath - 4.20
  13. The Pilot - 4.15
  14. Hell Bent - 4.13
  15. Before the Flood - 4.054
  16. The Zygon Invasion - 4.048
  17. Last Christmas 4.03
  18. Thin Ice - 4.01
  19. The Caretaker - 4.0
  20. The Girl Who Died - 3.98
  21. Time Heist - 3.96
  22. Death in Heaven - 3.95
  23. Into the Dalek - 3.87
  24. The Woman Who Lived - 3.85
  25. Robot of Sherwood - 3.66
  26. Smile - 3.64
  27. The Return of Doctor Mysterio - 3.61
  28. Kill the Moon - 3.53
  29. In the Forest of the Night - 3.35
  30. Sleep No More - 2.92
We'll have a new episode poll up for Knock Knock tonight!